Directors and Officers Insurance

Side A: Protecting Personal Assets of Individual Leaders

Side A coverage kicks in when the company cannot or will not indemnify its directors and officers. Think bankruptcy, insolvency, or situations where indemnification is legally prohibited. This is the most critical layer for individual leaders because it protects their personal wealth: bank accounts, real estate, investment portfolios.

For executives serving on boards, Side A is non-negotiable. Without it, a single claim could wipe out decades of personal financial planning. Many sophisticated buyers also purchase standalone Side A policies that sit above the main D&O program for an extra layer of personal protection.

Side B: Reimbursing the Entity for Indemnification Costs

When a company does indemnify its directors and officers (which most corporate bylaws require), it spends real money on legal defense and settlements. Side B reimburses the entity for those indemnification expenses.

This matters more than people realize. A complex securities case can generate legal bills exceeding $10 million before trial. Side B ensures the company's cash reserves and operating capital aren't depleted by defending its leadership against claims.

Side C: Entity Coverage for Securities and Corporate Claims

Side C protects the business entity itself. For public companies, this coverage typically only applies to securities claims, such as lawsuits alleging stock price manipulation or misleading financial disclosures. Private companies get broader entity coverage that can respond to claims from various sources, including competitors, vendors, and regulators.

This distinction between public and private company policies is one of the most misunderstood aspects of D&O insurance. Private companies often get more flexible coverage, while public companies need higher limits due to the scale of potential securities litigation.

Breach of Fiduciary Duty and Negligence Allegations

Directors and officers owe fiduciary duties to their organizations: duties of care, loyalty, and good faith. When a business decision goes badly, stakeholders often allege that leadership failed to exercise proper judgment or acted in their own interest rather than the company's.

These claims don't require proof of intentional wrongdoing. A board that approves a merger without adequate due diligence or an officer who fails to disclose a conflict of interest can face fiduciary duty claims even if their intentions were good.

Regulatory Actions and Employment-Related Lawsuits

Government agencies at the federal and state level regularly investigate corporate leadership for compliance failures. The SEC, DOJ, EPA, and state attorneys general all have the authority to bring actions against individual directors and officers.

Employment practices claims are another major source of D&O exposure. Wrongful termination suits, discrimination allegations, and wage disputes frequently name individual managers alongside the company. These claims have been rising steadily, particularly in states like California and New York with aggressive employment regulations.

Shareholder Disputes and Financial Mismanagement

Jarrod Schlesinger, Global Head of Financial Lines and Cyber at Allianz Commercial, notes that the environment for corporate management will continue to be defined by converging economic uncertainty, rapid technological change, and evolving regulatory expectations. Shareholder derivative suits and direct claims remain among the most expensive types of D&O litigation.

Financial distress is now the top indicator for future D&O claims, which is why underwriters apply intense scrutiny to balance sheets and debt loads. Companies experiencing cash flow problems or declining revenue should expect heightened exposure for their leadership teams.

Fraudulent Acts and Illegal Personal Profits

D&O policies won't cover directors or officers who commit fraud or gain illegal personal profits. These exclusions typically require a final adjudication: meaning a court must actually find the individual liable for fraud before the exclusion applies. Until that determination, the policy generally advances defense costs.

The nuance here matters. If an officer is accused of fraud but ultimately acquitted, the D&O policy should have covered their defense throughout the process. Review how your policy handles the advancement of defense costs before a final judgment.

Prior Acts and Known Litigation Exclusions

Because D&O insurance is claims-made coverage, the policy in effect when a claim is reported is the one that responds. Most policies exclude claims arising from wrongful acts the insured knew about before the policy's inception date. They also exclude pending or prior litigation that existed when the policy was purchased.

This creates a real trap for companies switching carriers. If your new policy has a retroactive date that doesn't reach back far enough, you could have a gap in coverage for past decisions. Work with an experienced advisor, like the team at Avery Insurance Agency, to ensure continuity when transitioning between carriers.

Factors Influencing D&O Insurance Premiums

Small businesses pay an average of $138 per month, or about $1,653 annually, for D&O insurance. Nonprofits can expect to pay between $1,500 and $5,000 per year for $2 million in protection. But these are averages, and your actual premium depends on several factors:

• Company size, revenue, and total assets
• Industry risk profile and claims history
• Number of directors and officers covered
• Financial health and debt-to-equity ratios
• Regulatory environment and litigation trends

The good news: the current D&O marketplace is generally favorable for insureds, with competitive renewal terms and aggressive new business offerings. That said, companies with weak governance practices or financial instability will still face higher premiums.

Public vs. Private Company Requirements

Public companies face mandatory SEC reporting requirements and shareholder class action exposure, which drives the need for higher limits and broader securities coverage. Private companies, while less exposed to securities litigation, still face significant risk from employee claims, regulatory actions, and contractual disputes.

One common mistake: private company owners assume D&O insurance is only for large corporations. In reality, any business with a board, investors, or lenders can face management liability claims. Companies that elevate governance above mere compliance will secure better terms and pricing on their D&O coverage.

Choosing the right D&O policy requires more than comparing premium quotes. Here's what separates well-protected companies from those that discover gaps after a claim:

• Request quotes from multiple carriers and compare not just price but policy language, exclusions, and sublimits.
• Ensure your policy includes coverage for regulatory investigations, not just lawsuits. Investigation costs can rival litigation expenses.
• Review the definition of "insured persons" carefully. Some policies cover only named officers, while others extend to all employees acting in a managerial capacity.
• Check whether defense costs erode the policy limit or sit outside it. An eroding limit means every dollar spent on lawyers reduces what's available for a settlement.
• Update your policy annually. Changes in revenue, board composition, acquisitions, or regulatory exposure all affect your coverage needs.

Mark Sutton, senior equity partner at Clyde & Co, observes that D&O policies are evolving to reflect a more complex regulatory environment, and underwriting discipline is tightening. Staying ahead of these shifts means working with an advisor who understands policy mechanics, not just pricing.

Avery Insurance Agency takes a consultative approach to D&O coverage, examining your company's specific vulnerabilities, board structure, and financial profile to build a program that actually protects your leadership team. With over 125 years of advocating for clients, they understand that management liability coverage isn't one-size-fits-all.

Directors and officers insurance isn't a luxury: it's a fundamental part of protecting the people who lead your organization and the entity itself. The risks are real, the claims are expensive, and the personal exposure for individual leaders is substantial. Getting this coverage right means understanding the structure, knowing the exclusions, and working with an advisor who will tailor the program to your specific situation. Reach out to Avery Insurance Agency to have a conversation about your management liability exposure and build a D&O program that lets your leadership team focus on running the business with confidence.

Your Life. Protected.

Complete Personal Insurance for Individuals Who Expect More

One Agency. Every Coverage You Need. No Gaps, No Surprises.

Protect Your Business & Livelihood

Commercial Insurance Solutions Designed for New England Businesses.

Comprehensive Commercial Coverage That Keeps Your Business Running

We Know Your Industry

Tailored Insurance Programs for the Industries That Drive New Hampshire

We Understand the Risks Your Industry Faces — and How to Manage Them

We Make It Simple

Getting Covered with Avery Is Easy

Step 01

Connect with an Avery Advisor

Call, email, or request a coverage online and we will respond the same business day.

Step 02

We Build Your Coverage Plan

We shop top-rated carriers, compare your options, and recommend the best fit for your needs.

Step 03

You Get Protected and Stay Protected

We place your coverage, review it annually, and advocate for you if you ever need to file a claim.

Insurance Tips & News

Stay Informed with the Avery Blog

Practical Insurance Advice for New Hampshire Families and Business Owners