Collector Car Insurance
Call Us: 603-766-3733
A 1967 Shelby GT500 sitting in your garage right now is worth somewhere north of $200,000. Your standard auto insurer doesn’t care. They see a 58-year-old car with a book value that reflects age, not desirability. If a pipe bursts and floods your garage, you’ll get a check that wouldn’t cover the engine rebuild, let alone the car. This is the fundamental problem with insuring collector vehicles through conventional policies, and it’s exactly why a specialized approach to insuring classic, vintage, and specialty automobiles exists. The right policy protects not just the car but the years of searching, restoring, and investing that went into it. Hagerty, Grundy, American Modern, Chubb, and Berkley One each approach collector coverage differently, and the policy language between them can mean the difference between a fully paid claim and a costly out-of-pocket surprise.
Understanding Collector Car Insurance vs. Standard Auto Policies
Standard auto insurance treats your car as a depreciating asset. The moment you drive off the lot, your coverage amount starts shrinking. For a daily driver, that model roughly works. For a 1970 Plymouth ’Cuda or a numbers-matching Porsche 911S, it’s a disaster.
Collector car insurance flips this model. These policies recognize that certain vehicles appreciate over time, that their value is subjective and market-driven, and that owners use them differently than commuter cars. The entire policy structure, from how value is determined to how claims are settled, is built around the reality of car collecting rather than the assumptions of daily transportation.
The Importance of Agreed Value Over Actual Cash Value
The single most important distinction is agreed value coverage. With a standard policy’s actual cash value approach, the insurer determines what your car is worth at the time of loss, factoring in depreciation. With agreed value, you and the insurer settle on a specific dollar amount when the policy is written. If the car is totaled, you typically receive that full amount with no depreciation, no haggling, no lowball adjuster estimates.
This matters enormously. A client with a restored 1969 Camaro Z/28 might agree on a value of $110,000. If the car is destroyed in a garage fire, they typically receive $110,000. Under a standard policy, they might receive $15,000 based on some algorithmic estimate that treats it like any other 56-year-old Chevrolet.
Qualification Criteria for Classic and Specialty Vehicles
Not every old car qualifies. Most specialty insurers require vehicles to be at least 15 to 25 years old, though some may cover newer limited-production models. You’ll typically need a separate daily driver, since these policies assume limited use. Insurers also generally want the car stored in an enclosed garage, not parked on the street.
Some providers may require photos and a professional appraisal. Others use their own valuation tools. The car generally needs to be in good to excellent condition, and modifications may affect eligibility or require additional documentation. Vehicles under active restoration can sometimes be covered, though the terms vary significantly between carriers.
By: Tod O’Dowd, CIC, CAPI
President of Avery Insurance Agency
Core Benefits: Flexible Usage and Spare Parts Protection
Beyond agreed value, collector policies may include benefits that standard carriers simply don’t offer. Two of the most valuable are flexible use terms and coverage for parts and tools.
Navigating Mileage Limits and Occasional Pleasure Use
Most collector policies restrict annual mileage, typically between 1,000 and 7,500 miles per year. This keeps premiums low, often 40% to 60% less than standard coverage for equivalent value. The trade-off is that you generally can’t use the car for commuting or daily errands.
That said, the definition of “pleasure use” has loosened considerably. Driving to a cars-and-coffee event, taking a weekend cruise, or even running an occasional errand is generally fine under most specialty policies. Some providers may offer tiered mileage plans, so if you actually drive your classic regularly on summer weekends, you can pay a bit more for 5,000 or 7,500 miles instead of being stuck at 2,500.
Coverage for Rare Components and Restoration Tools
Here’s something most people overlook: spare parts coverage. If you own a classic car, you probably have spare parts. NOS fenders, a rebuilt transmission, extra carburetors. These items can be worth thousands, and your homeowner’s policy likely won’t cover them adequately.
Specialty insurers may offer spare parts coverage ranging from $2,000 to $10,000 or more, depending on the carrier and form. Some policies may extend to shop tools and diagnostic equipment stored with the vehicle. For someone mid-restoration with $8,000 in parts on shelving, this coverage alone can justify the policy.
Specialty Collector Markets: Hagerty, Grundy, and American Modern
Three specialty carriers anchor the collector car market for the majority of enthusiasts. Each has a distinct personality and set of strengths, and the right fit depends on the vehicle, the owner’s usage pattern, and how the policy needs to coordinate with the rest of their personal insurance program.
Hagerty: Valuation Tools and Driver Club Perks
Hagerty is the largest specialty collector vehicle insurer in the United States, and their growth reflects the market’s trust. The company reported a 17% increase in total revenue to $1.456 billion for recent fiscal results, underscoring just how many collectors rely on their coverage.
Their valuation tool is genuinely useful, pulling from auction results and private sale data to help establish fair market values. Hagerty’s Driver Club membership may include roadside assistance, a magazine subscription, and access to events. For someone with a single classic car worth under $150,000, Hagerty is often a strong default choice.
Grundy: Long-Standing Specialist for Traditional Classics
Grundy has been insuring antique and classic vehicles for decades and tends to be a strong fit for traditional classics, pre-war vehicles, and modest-value collectibles. Their agreed-value program may offer straightforward underwriting and competitive premiums for owners whose cars don’t push into exotic territory. Where Grundy can stand out is on older or lower-value classics that other carriers price awkwardly.
American Modern: Broader Vehicle Appetite and Modification Flexibility
American Modern may accept a broader range of vehicle types, including exotics, muscle cars, modified vehicles, and vintage trucks. Their policies tend to be more flexible on modifications, which matters if your car isn’t bone stock. For owners with a resto-mod, a heavily modified Pro-Touring build, or a vintage truck that doesn’t fit a traditional concours profile, American Modern often deserves a quote.
High-Net-Worth Solutions: Chubb and Berkley One
For collectors with vehicles valued above $250,000 or multi-car collections worth seven figures, the conversation shifts to HNW carriers that integrate collector vehicle coverage with the rest of a sophisticated personal insurance program.
Chubb Masterpiece: Portfolio Coverage for Elite Collections
Chubb’s Masterpiece program is widely considered a benchmark for insuring high-value assets, and their collector vehicle coverage reflects that. They may offer blanket collection coverage, meaning your entire collection can be insured under one policy with individual agreed values. Claims handling typically leans white-glove, with adjusters who tend to understand the difference between a concours restoration and a driver-quality car.
Chubb’s program may also include broader coverage for in-transit risk, worldwide travel exhibitions, and integration with home, umbrella, and excess liability lines. For a collection that lives alongside a high-value home and meaningful liability exposure, the cohesion of a single Chubb program can be its own form of protection.
Berkley One: A Newer HNW Option with Growing Collector Appetite
Berkley One has expanded its private-client offering to include high-value collector vehicles in recent years. Their program may offer competitive agreed-value terms, integration with broader HNW home and auto lines, and a willingness to consider vehicles and operating patterns that other carriers approach more cautiously. As with every carrier in this tier, the actual breadth of coverage depends on underwriting and the specific form issued. An agency like Avery Insurance, with over 125 years of client advocacy, can help determine which of Hagerty, Grundy, American Modern, Chubb, or Berkley One may best fit your collection and overall asset profile.
Key Policy Add-Ons for Enthusiasts
The base policy is just the starting point. Several endorsements can significantly improve your protection.
Inflation Guard and Automatic Value Appreciation
The collector car market moves fast. A car insured for $80,000 three years ago might be worth $120,000 today. Inflation guard endorsements may automatically increase your agreed value by a set percentage annually, typically 4% to 8%, without requiring a new appraisal each year.
This is particularly important in a rising market. Without it, you’re responsible for tracking values and requesting increases, and most people forget until it’s too late. Some carriers may build this feature into their standard offering, while others treat it as an optional endorsement.
Nationwide Roadside Assistance and Flatbed Towing
Breaking down in a 1965 Mustang is a different experience than breaking down in a 2024 Honda Civic. You need flatbed towing, not a hook-and-chain wrecker that will destroy your front valance. Most specialty policies typically include flatbed-only roadside assistance at no extra charge, with towing limits often ranging from 100 to 150 miles.
Some carriers may also cover trip interruption: hotel and transportation costs if your car breaks down far from home during a rally or road trip. It’s a small benefit until you need it 400 miles from your garage.
| Feature | Hagerty | Grundy | American Modern | Chubb | PURE |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Agreed Value | Typically yes | Typically yes | Typically yes | Typically yes | Typically yes |
| Spare Parts Coverage | May offer to ~$10K | May offer, varies | May offer, varies | Custom limits | Custom limits |
| Mileage Options | Tiered, ~1K, 7.5K | Tiered options | Flexible tiers | Flexible | Flexible |
| Modern Exotics | Case-by-case | Limited | May accept | Typically yes | Typically yes |
| Inflation Guard | May be available | May be available | May be available | Often included | Often included |
| Flatbed Towing | Typically included | Typically included | Typically included | Typically included | Typically included |
Selecting the Right Provider for Your Specific Vehicle Type
The best insurer for your collection depends on what you own, how you use it, and what else you’re protecting. A single vintage truck worth $40,000 is often a Grundy or American Modern conversation. A three-car collection of air-cooled Porsches worth $600,000 combined may fit better with Hagerty or Chubb. A modern hypercar collection alongside a multi-million-dollar NH home calls for Chubb or Berkley One integrated with a broader risk strategy.
Here’s what that means for you: working with a consultative agency that represents multiple carriers makes this decision dramatically easier. Avery Insurance Agency places collector vehicle coverage across all of these providers, matching each client’s vehicles, usage patterns, and overall asset protection needs to the right carrier. That kind of tailored approach, built on actually understanding both the cars and the coverage, is what separates real protection from just having a policy.
Collector car insurance isn’t a commodity you shop by price alone. The interplay between agreed value, mileage tiers, spare parts coverage, and how the policy coordinates with your home and umbrella creates a coverage structure that demands expertise to get right. A small annual savings on premium means nothing if your policy underpays the claim you actually file.
Start by documenting your vehicles with current photos, recent appraisals where applicable, and an honest accounting of how you actually use them. Then work with an independent agency that understands the differences between Hagerty, Grundy, American Modern, Chubb, and Berkley One, and can match the right carrier to your specific collection and lifestyle. Your collection represents decades of passion and significant financial investment, and it deserves to be insured like it matters. Request Coverage through Avery Insurance to get started.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I insure a car that’s still being restored? Often yes. Many specialty carriers may offer coverage for vehicles under active restoration, with agreed value typically based on either the projected completed value or current investment, depending on the insurer and the stage of the project.
Do I need a separate daily driver to qualify? Almost always. Collector car policies typically assume limited, pleasure-only use, so insurers generally require proof that you have another vehicle for regular transportation.
What happens if my car appreciates beyond the agreed value? You should update your policy. Some carriers may include inflation guard endorsements that automatically adjust, but for significant market jumps, request a new appraisal and policy adjustment.
Are modifications covered under these policies? Generally yes, but you need to disclose them. Custom paint, engine swaps, and aftermarket upgrades should be documented and reflected in the agreed value. Undisclosed modifications can complicate claims.
How much less expensive is collector car insurance than standard coverage?
For a vehicle valued at $100,000, collector premiums typically run several hundred to a couple thousand dollars annually, compared to substantially more through a standard insurer. Limited use and secure storage are the main reasons specialty premiums tend to come in lower.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR:
Tod O’Dowd, CIC, CAPI
I'm the President of Avery Insurance Agency, a family-owned independent agency serving individuals and businesses across New England and in 40+ states. With a hands-on, consultative approach to personal and commercial risk, I help clients — from high-net-worth homeowners and contractors to restaurant owners and property managers — find the right coverage without the guesswork of working with a single-carrier agent.
What Our Clients Say
Trusted by Families and Businesses for Over a Century
Trusted by New Hampshire Families and Businesses for Over a Century
Your Life. Protected.
Complete Personal Insurance for Individuals Who Expect More
One Agency. Every Coverage You Need. No Gaps, No Surprises.
Home Insurance
Your home is your most valuable asset. Avery’s home insurance protects your property, belongings, and liability so you can feel secure no matter what happens.
High-Value Home Insurance
Own a home valued over $2 million? Our Premier Client Services program provides coverage built around high-value properties and the unique risks they carry.
Auto Insurance
Whether you drive a daily commuter, a classic car, or a motorcycle, Avery finds the right auto coverage for your vehicle and your budget.
Boat & Watercraft Insurance
From small boats on New Hampshire’s lakes to luxury yachts, Avery provides watercraft insurance covering your vessel, passengers, and liability on the water.
Umbrella / Personal Liability Insurance
An umbrella policy adds an extra layer of liability protection above your home and auto coverage. One of the most cost-effective ways to protect your financial future.
Valuable Possessions Insurance
Jewelry, art, collectibles, and other high-value items need coverage beyond a standard homeowners policy. Avery insures your most prized possessions at full appraised value.
Protect Your Business & Livelihood
Commercial Insurance Solutions Designed for New England Businesses.
Comprehensive Commercial Coverage That Keeps Your Business Running
General Liability Insurance
Protect your business from third-party claims of bodily injury, property damage, and personal injury. General liability is the foundation of any solid business insurance program.
Commercial Property Insurance
Covers your building, equipment, inventory, and other physical assets against fire, theft, vandalism, and other covered losses. Keep your business protected from the unexpected.
Workers’ Compensation Insurance
Workers’ comp covers medical costs and lost wages when an employee is injured on the job. Avery helps businesses meet state compliance requirements and manage costs effectively.
Cyber Liability Insurance
Data breaches and cyberattacks are a growing risk for businesses of all sizes. Cyber liability covers response costs, legal fees, and customer notification expenses after a security incident.
Employment Practices Liability Insurance
Covers your business against employee claims of wrongful termination, discrimination, harassment, and related issues. Essential for any business with employees.
Commercial Auto Insurance
Whether a single truck or a full fleet, commercial auto insurance protects your business against accidents, damage, and liability on the road.
We Know Your Industry
Tailored Insurance Programs for the Industries That Drive New Hampshire
We Understand the Risks Your Industry Faces — and How to Manage Them
Contractors Insurance
From general contractors to specialty trades, Avery understands the unique liability and property exposures your business faces on every job site in New England. We build coverage programs that keep your crew and company protected.
Restaurants & Hospitality
Restaurants, hotels, and marinas face distinct risks — from slip-and-fall liability to liquor liability and food spoilage. Avery designs coverage programs for the specific needs of the hospitality industry.
Real Estate & Property
Whether you own a portfolio of investment properties or manage a condo association, Avery provides the right mix of property, liability, and management coverage to protect your real estate investments.
We Make It Simple
Getting Covered with Avery Is Easy
Step 01
Connect with an Avery Advisor
Call, email, or request a coverage online and we will respond the same business day.
Step 02
We Build Your Coverage Plan
We shop top-rated carriers, compare your options, and recommend the best fit for your needs.
Step 03
You Get Protected and Stay Protected
We place your coverage, review it annually, and advocate for you if you ever need to file a claim.
Let’s Clear Things Up
Got Questions? We’ve Got Answers.
Straight Answers From the Advisors Who Know This State Best
What does it mean that Avery is an independent insurance agency?
An independent agency like Avery is not tied to any single insurance company. We represent multiple top-rated carriers, which means we can shop the market on your behalf and recommend the coverage that truly fits your needs — not the one that benefits any single insurer.
This independence gives you access to more options and unbiased advice. Our advisors are compensated to serve your interests, not to push a specific product. That is a significant advantage over captive agents who can only offer one carrier’s policies.
How much does it cost to work with an Avery advisor?
There is no direct cost to you for working with an Avery advisor. Independent agents are compensated through commissions paid by the insurance carriers when a policy is placed. You receive expert guidance, market comparisons, and ongoing service at no extra charge.
In fact, many clients find that working with Avery saves them money. Our advisors know how to identify the right coverage levels so you are not paying for protection you do not need, and you are not left exposed where you do.
Does Avery help with claims?
Yes — and this is one of the most important things that sets Avery apart. When you have a claim, our in-house claims advisors go to work for you. We guide you through the process, communicate with the insurance company, and advocate for a fair and timely outcome.
Several of our team members hold professional claims designations, including AIC and AINS. We do not just help you file paperwork — we actively represent your interests to make sure you receive the full benefit your policy provides.
Where in New Hampshire does Avery provide coverage?
Avery serves clients throughout the state of New Hampshire from our offices in Wolfeboro and Portsmouth. Whether you live in the Lakes Region, the Seacoast, the White Mountains, or the Merrimack Valley, an Avery advisor is ready to help you find the right coverage.
Our advisors understand the specific risks that come with living and doing business in New Hampshire — from harsh winter weather to seasonal watercraft exposure. We apply that local knowledge to every coverage recommendation we make.
How does Avery handle high-value homes and assets?
Avery offers a dedicated Premier Client Services program for clients with homes valued over .5 million, significant investment portfolios, fine art collections, jewelry, yachts, and other complex assets. This program pairs you with a specialist who understands the unique risks of high-net-worth households.
Through carriers that specialize in high-value personal lines, we provide guaranteed replacement cost coverage, agreed value policies, and comprehensive risk management strategies. Your advisor will conduct a detailed review of your full asset portfolio to make sure nothing is overlooked or underinsured.
How often should I review my insurance coverage?
Avery recommends a full coverage review at least once a year. Major life events — buying a home, starting a business, adding a vehicle, getting married, or making significant home improvements — are all good triggers for an immediate review outside your annual cycle.
Insurance needs change over time, and policies that were right for you a few years ago may leave gaps today. Avery advisors proactively reach out to clients for annual reviews and keep up with changes in the insurance market that could affect your coverage or premium. Our goal is to make sure you are always protected and never paying for coverage that no longer fits.
Insurance Tips & News
Stay Informed with the Avery Blog
Practical Insurance Advice for New Hampshire Families and Business Owners
Contact Us
Portsmouth (HQ)
7 Islington St #102, Portsmouth, NH 03801
Phone Number: 603.766.3733
Wolfeboro
21 S Main Street, Wolfeboro, NH 03894
Phone Number: 603.569.2515